Comparisons

Suno Alternatives, Compared by What You're Allowed to Do With the Song

Udio switched off downloads and Suno now rations them. I ran five prompts through six Suno alternatives and compared the terms, price and lyric accuracy.

MesmerTools•November 12, 2026•7 min

The way to choose a Suno alternative in 2026 is by what the terms let you do with the song, and whether they can change after you've made it. Udio switched off downloads after signing with Universal, and Suno's new terms, in effect since September 3, tie commercial use to a monthly allowance of downloads.

The one kind of option where nothing can be pulled is an open model under a clean license. ACE-Step 1.5 is MIT-licensed and costs about a cent a song through a hosted API, so on terms it's my pick. If you'd rather not host anything, Lyria 3.5 ($0.10 a song) and Mureka (about $0.23) charge per song. I ran the same five prompts through six alternatives and every track is on this page. I'm not ranking how they sound, so press play and judge for yourself. What I measured is lyric accuracy, price, length and speed.

An amber vinyl record with an open padlock on its label, next to a cloud connected by a cut dashed line

Udio turned off downloads, and Suno's new terms ration them

Udio signed with Universal in October 2025 and turned off downloads. Users got one 48-hour window in November to save their songs, and Udio's help center now says downloading of audio, video and stems “has been disabled.”

Suno settled with Warner a month later and launched its v6 models in September, retiring the older ones. Its new terms took effect on September 3. The free plan has no monthly downloads and no commercial rights. Pro ($10 a month) gets 20 downloads, Premier ($30) gets 60, and commercial use only covers songs you've downloaded. The download is now the unit you're paying for.

The legal fight isn't over either. Universal and Sony filed a second suit on September 18, alleging that v6 inherits the infringement of the earlier models. Suno says it trained v6 from scratch without their music. In July, in a case brought by GEMA, the German songwriters' society, a Munich court found that six songs, including “Daddy Cool” and the refrain of “Mambo No. 5”, were reproducibly contained in Suno's v3.5 and v4 models. Suno is weighing an appeal.

None of that tells you who wins. It shows which levers a music company pulls under legal pressure: downloads, model versions and license terms. Suno's own terms say commercial rights to a song you've downloaded are perpetual and survive cancelling. They also say Suno can change the terms whenever it likes, and that continuing to use the service counts as accepting the change. What you've downloaded is covered, and what you can make next month is up to Suno.

The Suno alternatives that matter, sorted by what you can do with the song

The rules about your song live in one of three places. In an app, they're on a terms page the company can rewrite. Through an API, you pay per song and get the file straight away, with no download allowance to run out. With open weights, the license ships with the model you download.

OptionCan you get the file?Can you sell or stream it?The catch
SunoFree: no monthly downloads. Pro ($10/month): 20 a month. Premier ($30): 60Pro and Premier: commercial use of downloaded songs. Free: non-commercialRights to downloaded songs are perpetual, but Suno can change its terms at any time
UdioNo. Downloading is disabledNothing to use without the fileSwitched off as part of its Universal deal
ElevenLabs MusicFree: no downloads. Starter ($6): 30 minutes a month. Creator ($22): 250 minutesPaid plans, except film, TV and radio. Streaming services need Creator or aboveA terms update that reduces your rights takes effect after 30 days' notice
MurekaDownloading is subscription-only; paid API calls return the filePaid plans and paid API calls include commercial rightsStop subscribing and the app stops letting you download
Google Lyria 3.5Yes, through the APIGoogle's API terms say it won't claim ownership of the outputEvery track carries a SynthID watermark
Stable Audio 3 (weights)You generate it on your own machineFree under $1M a year in revenue, and you own the outputThe license is revocable and ends once your revenue passes $1M
ACE-Step 1.5 (weights)You generate it on your own machineYes. MIT license, no revenue capYou run it, or pay someone to host it

As of October 2026.

APIs are steadier than apps, but they move too. MiniMax closed its paid music API to new users on August 20, though existing customers keep access and I could still reach the model through fal. The tracks I already generated aren't affected, but whether I can make more next month is up to MiniMax.

Open weights only help if the license is a good one. MIT has no clause that lets the authors take it back, and a copy you've downloaded keeps the license it came with. Stable Audio 3 is open too, but its community license calls itself revocable and ends once your revenue passes $1M a year.

A license on the weights also says nothing about what the model learned from, and the GEMA ruling was about exactly that: songs stored inside a model. ACE-Step's model card lists its training data as licensed, royalty-free and synthetic music. Stable Audio 3's lists licensed library audio plus Creative Commons recordings. Both are claims, not rulings, and a training-data lawsuit is the one risk a license can't cover.

Five prompts through six Suno alternatives

I wrote two songs with lyrics, about two minutes each, plus three 60-second instrumentals, and ran them through every alternative I could reach by API, keeping the first take each time. Use the tabs to switch prompts. There are no Suno tracks because I don't have an account.

“Upbeat synth-pop song with a female lead vocal. Bright and bittersweet, punchy drums, big singalong chorus, 112 BPM.”

Lyrics I gave every model

Coffee's cold on the windowsill / Your jacket's hanging where it hung before / I keep the radio on low / So I don't hear the quiet anymore // Turn it up, turn it up / Let the city sing it back to me / Turn it up, turn it up / I'm not waiting where you said you'd be // (second verse, chorus again)

ACE-Step 1.5

2:00 · $0.012 · 99% of lyrics heard

Lyria 3.5 (Google)

2:01 · $0.10 · 99% of lyrics heard

MiniMax Music 3

1:07 · $0.14 · 98% of lyrics heard

Mureka 9.5

2:28 long, first 2:00 here · $0.23 · 93% of lyrics heard

ElevenLabs Music v2.5

2:00 · $1.20 · 97% of lyrics heard

Stable Audio 3 Medium

Open weights, community license

Instrumental only, so it sat out the vocal prompts.

First take from each model, no rerolls, loudness-matched. Mureka ignores the requested length and writes full-length tracks, so those are cut where the others end. “Lyrics heard” is the share of my words that show up, in order, in a Whisper transcript. It tells you the words are intelligible, nothing about how the song sounds.

Every model that sings got my lyrics across. A Whisper transcript picked up between 93% and 99% of my words in order, so lyric accuracy doesn't separate them. The exception was ACE-Step's turbo variant, which dropped and garbled lines (69% and 80%). The base model, which is what you hear above, got 98% and 99%, so use base for songs with words.

Length is where they differ. Mureka ignores the length you ask for and returns a full song, between 2:28 and 3:34 here. MiniMax treats it as a ceiling: the two-minute pop song came back at 1:07, with 98% of the lyrics. ACE-Step, ElevenLabs, Lyria and Stable Audio landed within a few seconds of the request. On speed, Stable Audio took about seven seconds, MiniMax up to three minutes, and everything else roughly 15 to 65 seconds.

Most of them cost less per song than a Suno download

Price of one two-minute song with vocals, October 2026

ACE-Step 1.5 (Runware)
$0.012
Lyria 3.5
$0.10
Mureka 9.5
$0.23
MiniMax Music 3
$0.24
Suno Pro, per download
$0.50
ElevenLabs Music v2.5
$1.20
API list prices (ACE-Step is what Runware billed for my two-minute songs). MiniMax bills $0.002 a second, so two full minutes would be $0.24; mine came back shorter. Suno is Pro's $10 a month spread over its 20 downloads, if you use them all; billed yearly it's $0.40. Suno's price is per download and generating is separate, while the API prices are per generation, so rerolling multiplies them.

Lyria, Mureka and MiniMax all come in under a Suno download per song and never ration downloads. ElevenLabs is the outlier at $0.60 a minute. At a cent a song, ACE-Step is cheap enough to generate ten versions and keep one, and on your own GPU it costs nothing per song beyond electricity.

Build on ACE-Step, or pay per song

On terms alone, I'd build on ACE-Step 1.5. The license can't be pulled, there's no revenue cap, it runs on a consumer graphics card, and a hosted API costs about a cent a song. You can try it with your own prompt in our free AI music maker, which runs it on a hosted GPU and defaults to the base model. If you like what it makes, download the weights and the terms are yours for good. Songs from open models also mostly slip past AI-music detectors, which I tried in my AI music detector test.

If you'd rather pay per song, Lyria 3.5 is the cheapest hosted model I tested that sings, at $0.10, but every track carries Google's SynthID watermark, so anything that checks for it will flag the song as AI-made. Mureka sits around a quarter. For background music, Stable Audio 3 took about seven seconds and costs about four cents a track, as long as you stay under its revenue cap.

Whatever you pick, get the file. A song sitting in someone else's library is governed by whatever their terms say this month. A song on your disk, made by weights on your disk, stays under the license you downloaded.

More from the Blog